Archives: Gig Reviews

  • Duet Emmo

    Duet Emmo

    Well I don’t think anyone saw this one coming…

    Duet Emmo was a one-off project of which 1/3rd is Daniel Miller who created the startling ‘Warm Leatherette’ 7″, started Mute Records and basically invented synth pop. The other 2/3rd is Dome aka Bruce Gilbert and Graham Lewis of Wire. Between the end of Wire’s “imperial phase” (Pink Flag/Chairs Missing/154) and the beginning of their return as a technology driven ‘beat combo’ in the late 1980s, Dome released a series of extraordinary avant rock records that are absurdist, otherworldly and essential listening if you were wondering where the darker corners of ‘154’ and the infamous (official) bootleg ‘Document & Eyewitness’ may have taken Wire next. The sticker on their final album together brilliantly described them as ‘Post-Industrial chain-smokers’.

    Duet Emmo – an anagram of Dome & Mute was born from Bruce and Graham being a fixture at Blackwing studio in South London, the site of early recordings by Depeche Mode and Yazoo and helmed by one Eric Radcliffe (hence ‘Upstairs at Eric’s’) and between 1981-1982 they recorded one sole album ‘Or So It Seems’. It came out in 1983 to little fanfare although it did get a capsule review in Smash Hits magazine by one Neil Tennant who, while giving it a measly 5/10 summed it up well enough for pop crazed youngsters as “Chunks of tense electronic noises and throbbing and one dreamy song…”.

    Fast forward 43 years. Bruce Gilbert left Wire after their 3rd regeneration in 2004 to pursue sporadic solo releases and occasional live performances (ab)using electronics to his own menacing and uncompromising ends. Graham Lewis, while not averse to whipping up a maelstrom of electronic brutality himself continued with Wire who had a late-period hot streak and became an unmissable and intense live band throughout the 2000s and 2010s – all this ending abruptly, mid tour in the US as lockdown hit in 2020. Wire went home (Sweden, Brighton, London and a farm somewhere in the Midlands) and whether they will regroup again nobody knows (there is a significant anniversary coming up, and a crowd-funded documentary ‘People in a Film’ currently in Development Purgatory if not Hell)

    If being a seasoned fan of Wire and its variants teaches you one thing – expect the unexpected – but the first and only live performance by Duet Emmo was not on anyone’s bingo card. Their sole album has always had a cult following, a favourite of Wire fans who like the deep catalogue stuff and with a reissue in 2022 found a new audience for folk fascinated by the murkier corners of the early 80s hinterland of electronic experimentation. Darkwave, Coldwave? Something ‘wave’ anyway.

    And out of nowhere, a one off live performance at the ICA was announced a few months ago. The talk is this was an idea that was kicking around for a while, Daniel Miller being the driving force and possibly at a recent 80th birthday celebration for Bruce the deal was sealed – and here we are.

    Tonight in many ways is about the most unlikely participant -Bruce Gilbert. For many Wire fans he is what Brian Eno was to Roxy Music and his departure marks a dividing line for some – he’s perhaps the one who was always Artist over musician and defines Wire as an Art project rather than a mere ‘band’. Wire songs are ‘items’, Wire lyrics are ‘texts’. Bruce famously declared he doesn’t go out of his way to listen to any music at all and hasn’t since the early 1970s ¹. This is a man who once DJ’d as ‘DJ Beekeeper’ from inside a garden shed playing CDs with the front painted over so he didn’t know what they were. His solo work increasingly avoids melody, rhythm or anything too pretty or decorative.

    Suffice to say the prospect of Bruce, Graham and Daniel on stage means the Wire fanbase are out in force – pals from years of swapping stories and bootlegs on message boards (pre social media) and decades of live performances. The synth and electronica cognoscenti are here too. People have travelled from all over the country, from Ireland, from the US and that’s just the ones I spoke to. There is a buzz in the room – rumours abound that the group have only done a limited rehearsal, Bruce may or may not pick up a guitar again, nobody knows quite what to expect and nobody is expecting a slavish recreation of the album – but minds are open and happy with whatever this trio decides to throw at us.

    The setting is perfect – the ICA is a space for the Arts primarily so we’ve established the parameters from the off. This isn’t yer standard gig. Even better, the venue have put this on as part of their ‘In the Round’ series where artists perform in the centre of the venue and the sound system is also 360 degrees with scope for more than just left & right stereo. I’ve long argued that, particularly for electronic and more experimental work live music spaces could do so much more to create an immersive setting and this is a joy to experience and works brilliantly tonight.

    First to test the system is support act, the great Nik Colk Void. A perfect choice as she has played with Wire in her more upfront dance orientated group Factory Floor and collaborated with Chris & Cosey, Graham & Klara Lewis and New Order. She is used to playing to a crowd of greying post-punkers (although I note there is a younger demographic in here too).

    Tonight, Void pares it right back with a beatless set performed with a CD-J and analogue synth which takes advantage of the surround sound system as waveforms ping around the room – and reels the audience in. Setting the tone of tonight being about deep listening you can hear a pin drop and seems pretty much everyone has arrived early to catch this. The music is equal parts drifty and strangely beautiful while also amping up the tension somewhat with surges of bass drone. Void occasionally looks out into the crowd as if to figure out what to do next – whatever she was thinking the audience quietly take it in and a perfect set up to whatever is coming next –

    The stage is set for three artists in a semi circle and here they are. Daniel Miller sits behind a modest modular synth setup – a miniature version of the type of gear he would have used to create his early work with The Normal and Depeche Mode. Graham Lewis has laptops, mics, an array of fx-pedals and a bass guitar propped on a stand. Bruce Gilbert in leather coat and impressive head of shoulder length silver hair has (of course) the most idiosyncratic setup – one cheap Korg Volca synth, some rusty effects pedals and a battered sound mixer with an array of dodgy looking plugs and mains adapters. His MO is taking whatever noise makers he can find – never reading the manual and making them do whatever they weren’t designed to do. He’s not been persuaded to bring a guitar. Once Bruce has jabbed some wayward gear into action all sit down and hush descends – the set slowly builds from total silence an ominous but strangely appealing drone and the machinery starts glowing and literally crackles into life.

    Over time it becomes more obvious who is doing what -Bruce brings the noise – fizzing, crackling, the buzz buzz buzz in the drum of the ear. Not sure if anyone has ‘the master clock’ to keep things in time but Daniel Miller gradually brings in sequenced synth lines from his modular set up, Graham introduces stabs of chords that start to echo themes from the album and eventually starts to sing into a hand mic – alternating from his distinctive baritone, adding harmonising and pitching effects to his vocals to disorientate further. There’s a sense of relief that this is actually happening, it’s working and it’s sounding really good. They don’t seem to be using the 360 degree sound system as much as Nik Void was but it doesn’t matter – whatever is going on it’s utterly gripping and intense. There’s something happening here.

    The music starts to ebb away again and someone, presumably Bruce, is making a sound of what sounds either like a cat purring, or a fridge snoring – is he trolling the other two?

    Regardless there is a sense that this is all hanging by a thread and it’s all the more engaging as a result. As expected they don’t attempt to recreate the album in any conventional sense – but gradually from swirl of machinery emerges a familiar synth line and so begins the centrepiece – an extended ‘Or So It Seems’ (the “dreamy song” Neil Tennant was referring to) – it’s bleak and beautiful in equal measure – and as it builds Daniel starts to play with the sequence and things get nicely polyrhythmic. A kick drum threatens to emerge but never quite does.

    Bruce, concentrating deeply and occasionally sipping his drink now gets into spin cycle with his noise makers and something else emerges – Lewis picks up the bass guitar and we’re into a finale of extended visceral noise with electronic plips and blops raining down over the surge and rumble of Graham’s bass. It’s an exhilarating finale.

    A rapturous applause, a wry “you’re the best audience we’ve ever had” from Graham, and even the irascible Gilbert raises a smile when Lewis grabs him for a handshake. The unimaginable happened – it was brilliant and suffice to say there is unanimous agreement that was something very special indeed. I have been wrong before but it seems evident that was a total one-off (and walking past us Mr Gilbert later indicated so in brief and typical fashion when one of my party suggested it might become ‘a tour’). That’s it. So It Goes, or So It Seems.

    ¹ The Wire Issue 137 July 1995

  • Tara Clerkin Trio

    Tara Clerkin Trio

    In the “hipster haven” that is Ancoats, amid the crafty bars and restaurants you’ll find the beautifully restored and extended St Peter’s church which has been repurposed as the rehearsal space for the Hallé Orchestra as well as functioning as a community room and events space. Walking in – you know instantly you’re not in a “gig venue” – you’re in a cultural space and it feels warm, welcoming but also smart and spacious – we’re here to be enriched. Spaces like this are what makes a place like Ancoats more than just a cluster of city centre tower blocks thrown up to prise rents out of Gen Z – it’s the kind of thing that makes this place feel more like a neighbourhood people might want to make their home rather than just a bunch of tarmac between apartment & city centre – and it is a fantastic way of preserving the rich history of the area.

    They put on occasional gigs too – and it’s the perfect setting for tonight’s performance from Tara Clerkin Trio. The show is sold out but seated – with plenty of room in the spacious room for the music to breathe. Gigs aren’t just about a band in a room, if you’re doing it properly it’s about getting the right combination of music, performance and setting and tonight its absolutely perfect. Support comes from the excellently named Ana Palindrome over from Cork, Ireland. Combining violin, bass and keys and vocals they’re a beguiling mix of folk, art-pop and electronics delivered with wit and a playful approach to rhythm. The audience are receptive and in listening mode and apart from the clack of beer cans being opened everyone engages with the music – They charm us and they may just charm you too.

    I’m a firm fan of Bristol’s own Tara Clerkin Trio – their smart use of loops, hip hop and drum & bass rhythms reminds me of the late 90s Post Rock scene (Bark Psychosis, Disco Inferno, Pram, Laika) that was swept away by the retro-mania of the Shed Seven era. Post Rock might not be a reference point for the band but they really do sound like Britpop never happened. You could be forgiven for thinking they’re a jazz combo (not least by the name) and indeed they use the toolkit of Jazz – unusual chord voicings, a drummer playing with brushes, a double bass on occasion and a clarinet – but they’re not about solos and jazzy noodling. At the heart is repetition and small details adding to the sum of their parts. At their best they’re about finding an intriguing melodic pattern and letting it cycle around until it forms some strange logic- it’s a trick they pull off several times tonight.

    TC3 having sold out two nights at the ICA in London and several other dates with a mighty fine new record ‘Something Good’ to share. They open with ‘Ups & Downs’ which really is quintessential TC3 – a loping beat, circular double bass line (set up as a loop live by multitasking drummer/bassist Sunny Joe) haunting chords, choral samples and strings and tinkling piano. Like the rest of the set the song has room to evolve a bit more and become beautifully hypnotic. The title track revolves around an infectious two chord riff off tremolo guitar – mesmerising repetition gorgeous overlapping harmonics and a dub bass undertow. ‘Movin’ On’ is a real contrast with its clash of fractured breakbeats and wayward samples – a plunderphonic delight.

    Anyone expecting a recap of some of their earlier recorded highlights to date will be…absolutely delighted actually as they not only play choice cuts from the new one but delve into their back catalogue for a career spanning overview too. Older tracks like ‘On the Turning Ground’ with it’s delightful chiming acoustic figure, sweeping strings and dubbed out breakbeats fits in perfectly with the newer material.

    TC3 are a joy to watch, they have a wry sense of humour and they’re accessible and engaging – and the atmospheric setting is the perfect place to appreciate them. They close with ‘Slow Island’ – a slow burning mix of dub bass and echoed piano with lead vocals shared by Tara and Sunny Joe (“my Ringo moment” he says as steps in front of the kit to sing). Inspired and inspiring stuff – we leave enriched.

  • White Flowers + Powders

    White Flowers + Powders

    It’s a Prestonian double bill in the bestest of basements tonight. First up are Powders -a two piece – one with a bank of electronics and one with a Cello – manipulated through FX and loopers. The sound is atmospheric and experimental – occasionally surges of noise and sub-bass give way to barely there crackles and environmental samples and the lonely pluck of a string – at one point the sound ebbs away leaving just a sample of running water – and the crowd fall silent unsure of whether to applaud – they’re in listening mode which is necessary with this music (the Cellist breaks the fourth wall and reassures us it’s OK to clap between songs). The electronics occasionally generate the echo of a broken rhythm machine- scraping over the surface of the reverberations of the Cello – never quite taking flight – instead they maintain a tension right to the end. Excellent stuff.

    Fellow Lancashire lad and alumni of Preston School of Art, John Foxx is playing over the PA while White Flowers get their gear ready which is a nice touch (assuming not a coincidence) – and indeed his glacial electronic rhythms and breezy European cool is a good fit for White Flowers. Their 2nd album ‘Dreams for Somebody Else’ sees them adding cinematic synths, arpeggio basslines and a solid bass drum kick to their shoegazey gothic melodramas. Have a listen

    Last time I saw the band was at a socially distanced gig in 2021 -seated and masked. It was inevitably weird but also moving and quietly celebratory and a welcome chance to feel vaguely normal again. It’s great to be back with them in a more conventional setting standing with a pint of warm lager and a capacity crowd. Tonight they’ve expanded to a 3 piece. It’s not unfair to say that Joey and Katie have never been ones for throwing shapes and being overly performative in concert so the addition of a live drummer adds some welcome forward propulsion and energy right from the off.

    The set is largely drawn from the new album – this is BIG music for such a small stage but the excellent sound mix does their soaring new repertoire justice. We’re talking ‘Disintegration’ era Cure, New Order when they were doing things like ‘Temptation’ combining twanging basslines with fizzing pop rhythms. They haven’t completely ditched the Cocteau Twins influence of their earlier work – the bass into to ‘Heaven’ for instance nods toward ‘The Spangle Maker’ before switching into a sublimely catchy tune full of hooks – this is ambitious stuff and White Flowers as ever make it look easy. The mix of danceable rhythms and soaring melodic rainshowers is hugely compelling – an hour in White Flowers world is warm and enveloping. They can dial it back too and there’s lots of more restrained moments especially the title track from the new record all adding to a perfectly pitched set. They’re a bit under the radar these – get scanning and find them on yours…

  • Manchester Psych Fest 2026

    Manchester Psych Fest 2026

    I remember when Psych Fest was just a diy all-dayer at Night & Day cafe. It’s now a multi-venue affair, firmly established on the Manchester scene, attracts people from far and wide and this is the biggest one yet. There are also sister events in Brighton and Edinburgh so like Reading & Leeds Festivals they can exchange headliners across a weekend with local artists making up the rest of the bill.

    When the festival began, as now, the definition of ‘Psych’ is up for debate and has a increasingly fluid meaning much like ‘Post Punk’ or even ‘R&B’. 30 years ago you might expect a bill to include bands like Gong or Ozric Tentacles, maybe some electronica like The Orb. Now ‘psych’ is basically a catch-all for bands with (mostly) guitars with a broadly ‘Indie’ aesthetic- but ‘Psych’ is supposed to infer a more experimental, freewheeling variant More ‘Freak Zone’ than Radio X. More Stereolab than Shed Seven.

    Mid afternoon and the freaks are out in force moving around the venues, wrist bands and ‘Clashfinder’ at the ready (or the slightly clunky ‘official app’). Usually Psych Fest is centred around the ‘Oxford Road Corridor’ (as developers call it) where there is a cluster of gig venues around The Ritz, Gorilla, Yes, Bread Shed, Deaf Institute and sometimes reaching over to the Albert Hall and even a skate park under the Mancunian Way. This year it’s gone to the another level with both the 2,600 capacity Academy and the 3,500 capacity Apollo Theatre pressed into service, extending the festival map even further.

    Bringing the Apollo into the mix does make it less easy to dive in and out of venues – at a push you can get there in 20 minutes from the festival hub in Circle Square, or even hop on a 192 bus, but this negates the ‘lucky dip’ ethos of the event a bit. I suspect the growth in scale may be partly due to one band in particular – the viral “sensation” Angine du Poitrine which the internet has been losing it’s collective shit over for months. Whether they are actually any good or not is hard to say because the relentless algorithmic hype behind them drowns out the music, but the weight of FOMO around them is palpable. With a multi-venue festival there is always the possibility you won’t get in to one of the more popular shows. To be honest, I don’t care how many notes they can play at once – I’m quite happy to miss out on Polka-dot Noseybonk and his pal and opt to watch a few other bands rather than queuing halfway round Ardwick Green. (I hear on the grapevine that a lot of AdP fans just pitched up in the Apollo for Gwenno’s set and hogged the space thereafter – and were talking loudly during the act that didn’t have the Polka Dot gimmick – inevitable I suppose)

    Anyway, Psych Fest is very much a ‘choose your own adventure’ affair and it’s worthwhile doing some research on Bandcamp, a bit like the Christmas Radio Times, underlining the turns you might like to see. There are, inevitably, clashes which are deliberately timed to split the audience between the bigger acts. For instance Stereolab, Allah-Las and Bdrmm are all on at once. Beta Band, White Denim and Ty Segall clash (find out who I chose later!) suffice to say one of the reasons the tickets are so affordable (especially if you book early) is you will have to make some tough decisions over who you want to see.

    Our day begins at the good old Ritz to see Lael Neale. Joined by a keyboard/guitarist I’m taken by Lael’s deceptively simple songs – keyboard and guitar based, drone and 2-chord trick based drawing obvious comparisons with Spacemen 3/Sonic Boom or Galaxie 500. Lael has a secret weapon which is a surprisingly powerful voice and ability to do a bit of a Tim Buckley-esque soaring vibrato which she does, sparingly so as not to overdo it but to striking effect. It’s relatively slight and delicate music at times – challenging put over in one of the larger gig rooms – but the audience ‘get it’ and Lael goes down a treat.

    Staying in The Ritz, the seldom used (and notoriously hot and humid) 2nd venue underneath is open for Psychfest – one of the smallest spaces in fact and I stick around to see the intriguing Roscoe Roscoe – a raggedy and rather earnest looking bunch – lots of instrument swapping and one or two fluffs here and there “blowing off the cobwebs” as they put it – but I’m rather taken with them and stay for the whole set as do the engaged crowd gathered here. The songs are delicate, hard to pin down and often using layered vocal harmonics, complex interlocking parts and veering into odd time signatures in the post-rock vein of These New Puritans or Bark Psychosis. It’s hesitant and understated at times but I rather like that and I’m looking forward to seeing what they do next.

    Time for some venue hopping – I catch a bit of Renni Conti with his band in the basement of Yes – on record the music is quite dreamy and string laden, stripped to a four piece rock band it reminds me more of Pavement but there is a clever songwriting at play here. ‘Leaving the Zoo’ is particularly striking and has a nice mix of sweet sounds and grungy guitars.

    Over at the aforementioned Skate Park, I catch Ghostwoman. One of the stranger spaces in use, it works quite well as a semi-open air venue (with a roof) albeit with some awkward standing arrangements on various ramps and curves and platforms (complete with thrown trainers hanging off the metalwork above the crowd). The band are a two-piece drummer and guitarist who share vocals. They lean into the guitar grinding riffs and distorted vocal/slapback echo thing on the mic that is a bit of trope of the more OhSees/Ty Segall brand of psych rock – which isn’t to my taste and a bit wearing on the ears albeit they whip up an impressive head of steam and the crowd around me love ’em – but the beauty of today is I can nip down the road and find something else…

    Over at the Bread Shed I find (forever to be misspelled) The Heavenly Bodes – from Penryn in Cornwall – now this is more like it. Proper 60s Garage rock unashamedly ‘Nuggets’ style, pudding bowl haircuts and lots of rock action on stage and Fun Fun Fun. They jingle, jangle and make everyone smile.

    Now comes the first mega-clash of the day. I could see my beloved Stereolab, west coast janglers Allah-Las or Hull shoegazers Bdrmm. I decide to pass on Stereolab at the Apollo as I’ve seen them many times and by all accounts the set is drawn from the exact same repertoire (mostly from the current LP) I saw them play back in December and reviewed here. I plump for Bdrmm as I could do with some more electronic based music after all those guitar riffs and I suspect they may have some new music to play (which they do). I’m not the only one as the Ritz is packed and Bdrmm seem genuinely humbled at how many have shown up to see them. They rise to the occasion and put in a visceral and passionate performance. It’s good to see them able to space themselves out on a much bigger stage than I’ve seen them previously and they also show their songs benefit from room to breathe and easily fill the big old Ritz ballroom. There is still that self-deprecating “we’re from sunny Hull”, DiY modesty about them and their daft band name (which they are now stuck with) but they are clearly transcending that and I see before me a band maturing into something potentially rather dramatic.

    I attempt to see Atlanta duo Lowertown at the basement at Yes but this is my first and only lock-out of the night and instead head over to see US/Mexican band Holy Wave – they’re intriguing and perhaps my favourite discovery of the day. They make up for missing Stereolab as they have a line in exotic melodies and tropicalia that isn’t a million miles away (one of the band sports a ‘lab shirt just in case there was any doubt) but with nods toward kosmiche rock and good old guitar-fx laden shoegaze. A mish-mash but a very enjoyable one.

    So finally over to the Apollo – taking a short cut via Grosvenor Street in Brunswick where modernised low-rise social housing competes for breathing space with student tower blocks and the expanding city centre looming around it. I’m wondering if there will be a queue for Beta Band – there is not and the security staff are packing away the crowd control barriers presumably set up for the Angine du Poitrine shenanigans. In fact the venue is half full at best, with stiff competition from Ty Segall and White Denim across town.

    I’m curious rather than desperate to see Beta Band again and I must admit to being a bit dismissive of the news last year that they were touring again not least because I saw them a couple of times in the 90s they were pretty listless and soporific in concert. Admittedly I only saw them once they’d got to mid-sized venue stage and didn’t see what were probably quite exciting early gigs. I also don’t think I’ve listened a Beta Band record in 20 or so years – they were interesting for a fleeting moment for me. Reports from the comeback gigs have been positive and suggest they have got their shit together and out of three clashing headliners they’re an easy win for me.

    After some preamble including a video montage and David Bowie’s ‘Memory of a Free Festival’ over the PA the band file on in their jump suits surrounded with odd foliage and a weirdly gloopy pink lighting scheme which is a bit unsettling and off they go. The sound is a bit reverby, especially the drums so it all sounds a bit soupy at first and makes me think Beta Band’s idiosyncratic and wayward songs were really designed for much smaller venues – but it starts to settle in after a while and your ears adjust to the strange logic of Beta Band. They Start Making Sense. I also note that the band – especially Steve Mason and keyboard player John Maclean – are making efforts to ‘mach schau’ albeit the lighting is such that the band are always in shadow and creates a barrier between them and the audience. There is lots of instrument swapping between drums, guitars and percussion and as they play through cuts from the early EPs and their patchy subsequent LPs (including a rambling ‘It’s Not too Beautiful’ from their self-sabotaged debut album). Hypnotic loops like ‘Push it Out’ just about work in the huge venue but inevitably ‘Dry the Rain’ lands the best and the audience respond with a huge singalong and ‘The House Song’ which becomes a full-on percussion workout and once last dance-off.

    For some this is deeply nostalgic, for me it’s interesting to listen again and I’m struck by what an odd and curious band the Beta Band were, and still are. You could argue that such was the buzz around them back in the 90s they were the Angine de Poitrine of their day except that the hyperbole and excitement was generated in print media rather than online as the internet was in its infancy back then. We’ll see whether AdP mount their own comeback 30 years from now…

    Psychfest goes on into the night for them with the stamina or a second wind, but when the Bee Network goes to sleep, so PhoningItIn.blog must retire to bed too and dream of what Greater Manchester would be like if it had something like Greater London’s late running transport network… – so we don’t get to catch the return of Working Men’s Club, the intriguingly named Annabella Chairlegs or the appropriate choice of Nightbus (seen ’em before and very good they are too) who mop up the last dregs at 1.30am. I do not feel remotely short changed though and worth every penny of the reasonably priced early-bird ticket – book now for 2027 you psychedelia crazed youngsters!

  • EarthBall

    EarthBall

    I sometimes dread the question “who are you going to see tonight”. It’s usually some underground combo with an unpronounceable, clunky or unwieldy band name (as is the fashion these days) that I feel a bit apologetic about. No such problem with EarthBall – an excellent band name and one you can say with some relish, perhaps emphasising the word ‘Earth’ like Peter Wyngarde in the 1980 Flash Gordon movie “…The inhabitants refer to it as the planet..eeeuugghhrthh”.

    However, I’ve been quite amused by the reaction when saying EarthBall will be peforming a free rock improvisation – cue horrified reactions from otherwise learned and cultured friends and acquaintances “that sounds hideous!”. I’m quite tickled by that. In 2026 it’s quite nice that there is anything musical that people would find quite so beyond the pale. Of course with the words ‘free’ and ‘improv’ everyone probably has different ideas of what that actually means. To some it could mean what the Americans call “Jam bands” – hours of fretwankery and muso showboating at Arena filling scale – more like a sporting event than a gig – an appalling idea that I’d also run a mile from. It could also mean just downright bad or just plain boring music -people bashing away aimlessly on some instruments to no particular end. But why would anyone do that?

    Free improvisation though, to me at least implies that some thought, discipline, Art and downright nerves of steel is involved – to walk out on stage with (tonight) a five piece band with neither band nor audience knowing quite what is going to happen is quite something and has a different set of parameters to just a regular gig where there is a setlist . Of course we’re here because EarthBall have a reputation for being very good at this sort of thing – they’ve been on the front cover of The Wire magazine. The comedian Stewart Lee is a fan – (he was accidentally sampled on one of their recordings) and highly likely he would be here tonight if he wasn’t across town playing an outdoor gig in Castlefield Bowl. There are lots of recorded works so you get the general idea – we are here because we buy into the general idea of what Earthball are and we can expect it will probably get loud and visceral and exciting.

    It’s incredibly refreshing in a way. Earthball have come over from Canada and file on amid the glitterball sparkles in the Kamera ballroom. They are a 5 piece tonight. Two guitars, sax player, bass, drums (with some percussion and keys and other things to bash if necessary and other brass instruments and things as required) – tonight as with every time they play it will be different, there’s no ‘bangers’ that everyone is expecting, no nostalgia, no instant gratification – they’re just going to start playing and see what happens. The nearest comparison I can make is The Necks – except they fall more into the Jazz area and require a high spec Grand Piano to be provided by the promoter.

    It feels churlish to lift a phone and take a picture but I need one for the review – so I quickly take a few snaps and as you can see it’s grainy and blurry – proof that you can’t really capture what EarthBall are doing in the moment so best put your phone away and engage – which everyone does.

    They start with a crash of drums and a guitar chord or two, but also with moments of silence. A secret weapon for any improv combo – leave a space where a conventional band wouldn’t dare – stare the audience out. The sax player eventually decides to fill the gap. There are vocals from two of the musicians – mostly speaking, intoning or occasionally bellowing whatever springs to mind – so this is very much about communication not just ‘playing’. Without wanting to resort to lazy comparisons – think Sonic Youth’s spoken word passages, or Throbbing Gristle when the Cornet and feedback guitar comes out. Things begin quite abstract and and just as I’m wondering if there will be much in the way of rhythm – suddenly the drummer does exactly that and it’s clear that comparisons others have made to Can and King Crimson are on point.

    The set seems to move through 4 or 5 ‘pieces’ if you like – at one point settling into a very bass heavy almost gothic whirpool of a riff – and I swear at one point one of the guitarist has some sort of talkbox on his guitar – Peter Frampton-style but I can’t be sure. Which is a theme of the performance – you find yourself looking round the stage wondering who is making the various sounds – some familiar, some not. They slip into a vaguely conventional post-punk bass and guitar thing for a bit – and I like the fact that EarthBall can improvise something that sounds like a track of one of the early albums by The Cure as if that’s exactly what you’d expect them to do – before it all shatters again.

    The set is just 45 minutes which seems to be their MO. It leaves us wanting more which is a smart move – going back to the general ‘fear of improv’ I like that there is a time frame to this – an exercise in brevity and self-editing and EarthBall never once sound indulgent or flabby – and 45 minutes is roughly the length of an album. Perfect. Look at it this way – every night they perform an album you’ll hear once, and never hear again. It might be really good too. This one was!

    It made me think bands doing free improv should probably be more of a ‘thing’ on the regular gig circuit – rather than a niche . I will be at Manchester Psychfest this weekend and will mostly be listening to bands who are claiming to push at the boundaries and take us on some sort of freewheeling ‘trip’ – but all with a thoroughly rehearsed and tested setlist, aiming to please and sell some merch. There won’t be much genuinely free or improvised music, and outside of venues like Cafe Oto in London and tiny underground spaces this sort of thing is incredibly under the radar or hidden away – when it should be above and open for all – I’d certainly like more of “this sort of thing” and the full venue agrees. Hats off to promoters Alphaville and the Kamera venue for putting this on.

  • Golomb at The Abbey

    Golomb at The Abbey

    Forgive me, I’ll get to the band, but first I want to talk about our newest Manchester venue. We’re in the middle of what was once an inner city suburb of Manchester called Greenheys. In the 1800s an affluent semi-rural area (and home to original Madchester drug enthusiast Thomas De Quincey, socialist Robert Owen and Sir Charles Halle) before the Industrial Revolution turned it into a traditional estate of back-to-back terraced streets by the 1890s when The Old Abbey was built. A place that generations called home. By the 1970s, the bulldozers moved in and the whole neighbourhood was gone again. Pretty much all that remains was The Old Abbey – one of those wonderful ‘blot on the landscape’ pubs that cannot be destroyed by conventional means and remains while everything around it changes beyond recognition. See also The Salutation up the road from here, and the Star and Garter next to Piccadilly Station – immovable objects refusing to budge as developers erect drab student flats and soaring skyscrapers around them.

    Unlike the rest of Hulme and Moss Side next door – Greenheys didn’t turn into new housing development and instead The Old Abbey found itself no longer the pub on the corner, but strangely marooned in the middle of a huge Science Park where it now hides -a wonderful anomaly amid anonymous looking office units, labs and University buildings and strangely bland and artificial looking bits of landscaping and greenery (apparently home to over 150 businesses but deserted at night).

    In recent years The Abbey was a lesser known part of the ‘Kro’ chain of Manchester bars, before becoming a makeshift but thriving community pub/hub which unfortunately closed down in 2025. Local music promoters Now Wave came to the rescue (of the building at least) and the pub has been given a refurb and a purpose built live music space added at the back (along with a spruced up beer garden). It’s very much being promoted as ‘Old Pub, new music’ rather than purely a venue. Once again the beer flows as do in-depth pub conversations, music, games, hot pies and crisps.

    Walking in the smartly restored entrance you enter what feels like an old pub that has been there forever, it feels lived in rather than ‘poshed up’ and hopefully anyone who remembers the old days will feel reasonably at home in the snug. Through a door past the bar is a neat little annexe housing a wood panelled venue, almost like a miniature version of the lovely New Century Hall. Modern lighting effects combine with a glittery silvery backdrop curtain that might have felt at home in it’s 1960s heyday.

    It’s a small room, probably around the capacity of the basement venue at Yes but more opened out and a higher ceiling. It’s a really well laid out space clearly built with music in mind – there’s a mini bar, a ticket window and – the one thing so many live venues forget (and so important to touring bands this century)- a dedicated space for bands to set their merchandise out which is conveniently placed on the way in/out of the gig room. One criticism – there is no air conditioning (yet?) and it is very clammy and stuffy on a moderately warm night – with a capacity crowd in a heatwave it’d be unbearable. All in all though, a great restoration of what could easily have been a lost pub. It does feel in the middle of nowhere that’s also part of it’s charm and it’s only really a short 10 min stroll from Hulme, the Academy venues on Oxford Road and the University.

    Oh yeah, the gig. Tonight’s turn are Golomb, all the way from Columbus, Ohio. Another great band with a confusing name (see every single Indie band ever since 2020). My immediate response is to assume they are some of sort of unimaginative Prog Rock band who are reaching for something Tolkien-esque for inspiration but is apparently the maiden name of one of the band members, and they are not Prog Rock (well maybe slightly). They are a three piece – married couple Xenia on Bass and vocals, Mickey on guitar/vocals and Xenia’s brother Hawken on Drums. A family affair then. I’m sure other writers would get several paragraphs out of how that shapes their sound and songwriting – I’ll just say it probably saves on hotel bills on tour.

    There is something reassuring about an effortlessly cool looking girl and two boys who walk on stage, take their time plugging in and getting settled while a feedback loop gradually gets louder and louder – calm and collected and sure enough as soon as they launch into the first song – a brilliantly simple Velvet Underground riff with a catchy chorus – ‘Real Power’ – I’m immediately “in”. It’s loud, melodic and irresistible. They’re not a one-note drone rock band either, they can meander a bit – with Mickey seemingly making the sound that Sonic Youth need 3 guitars to achieve, not one. Xenia on bass drives along at points almost overwhelming the sonics but she also knows when to leave gaps and as the set progresses things veer into spacier territory and the basslines veer dubwise . Things get quite Spacemen 3/Sonic Boom at times too and no surprise that the latter has contributed a remix for the band’s latest excellent record ‘The Beat Goes on’.

    Golumb have tunes to burn, and a really natural easy chemistry as a band that makes them really appealing to listen to. They don’t play safe either, every time you think they’re settling into something generic they take it somewhere slightly off – suddenly segue into a new song, or extend it or bend it out of shape – and there are lots of changes of pace and mood. They can do sharp, short pop songs but they can also do extended wig-outs and slow burning drones without descending into hackneyed ‘psych rock’ cliches and you’re never far from another choppy riff and a sharp hook. They are the very definition of a Power Trio. Go and follow Golomb.

  • The Cure

    The Cure

    Manchester loves a massive gig, and not content with having two enormodomes and 2 football stadiums, it also turns it’s two biggest municipal parks over for live music in the summer too. Heaton Park famously hosted the run of Oasis shows last year, and the annual rite-of-passage rave for hedonistic teenagers ‘Parklife’. At the southern end of the city is the lesser known Wythenshawe Park and very lovely it is too boasting a historic hall, a proper city farm, wildflower gardens and makes for a suitably enjoyable stroll deep into the park for this evenings show. Headlining are the unmissable, global (never mind national) treasure that is The Cure.

    The show sold out in milliseconds not least because the band have made a stance against extortionate soaring ticket costs and ‘Dynamic pricing’. They could probably have charged a lot more – Oasis, Harry Styles, Taylor Swift and countless others certainly do and seem quite happy to turn their fans upside down and shake every last penny out of their pockets. The fact that a band with a colossal global fanbase like The Cure is making a stand against the pure, cynical greed endemic in the live music industry is very important. They have proved it doesn’t have to be that way.

    The park is gradually filling and there are loads of folk who’ve made the effort to dress for the occasion – dapper post-punk clobber, full on goths, lots of make-up, leather and lace, tats and piercings and pretty much everyone is in varying degrees of black. Very much a multi-generational, all ages, whole families of fans that embrace The Cure as a look as much as the music and proudly wear their musical allegiances on their t-shirts. But civilians are welcome too, The Cure after are a great rock band, a great Indie band, a great Pop band, even a great Dance band at times- something for everyone. We like Cure people – we’re among friends it seems.

    PhoningItIn is there in time to catch Slowdive‘s support set and while it can’t compare to seeing them in full, reverb drenched flight indoors they still make an impact in the early evening sun. Like the headliners, Slowdive have found they resonate with the younger generation and have a whole new audience – they’re the Shoegaze Fleetwood Mac in that sense, and are enjoying a well deserved second act in the 21st century and now way bigger than they ever were in the early 90s. They have a finely tuned support set which shows the songs from their most recent two albums such as the soaraway ‘Star Roving’ are as good, if not better than their first wave. I can’t help wondering if bass player Nick has got some tips from the Cure’s Simon Gallup as his bass is particularly crisp and strident, slung low and almost the lead instrument as the immense wash of guitars builds behind him. Outdoor gigs can be notorious for dodgy, drifty sound but Wythenshawe Live have got a magnificent sound system and even at the back it is loud, clear and immersive. Sure enough – Slowdive get some goosebumps going as the pedals hit ‘stun’ and the guitars explode into space. Fantastic.

    As people mill around getting chips and pints the backing music becomes more orchestral and moody gradually morphing into the sounds of gathering storms and rain (the actual forecast rain does not dampen the evening) – it’s almost comically gothic and then right on cue 20.15 Friday Night and here are The Cure.

    They have a habit of doing long, slow burning sets so we’re eased in with the brooding and dramatic ‘Alone’ from the new record – time for Robert to pace around and eye the audience and get the measure of us. Only The Cure could start a gig with the words “This is the end of every song that we sing – alone”. One of the reasons they resonate so much with a new generation is they confront the sadness and worry of our grim times but we also know that the bittersweet ‘Friday I’m in Love’ is going to be on the setlist – we’re ready for wild mood swings because life can’t be one long Champagne Supernova can it?. The Cure truly are a band of the people.

    What immediately stands out is Robert Smith’s vocals. We can forgive artists of a certain age a bit of gruffness, thinning power and even using a bit of technology to assist them. None of that is needed here. He is 67 and has clearly taken care of his pipes and sounds absolutely identical to his younger self – pitch perfect, soaring and every so often doing a magnificent ascending “woooooooooaaaaaahhhhhhhh!” He is on stunning form throughout and giving it genuine gusto for over 2 hours. He is also dressed, and made-up as “Robert Smith”. Some may question whether a man of 67 should still be rocking the same look he did 40 years ago but I say yes! He looks brilliant – the gothic barnet is thinning only a little but frankly the fact that he insists on donning the eyeshadow and lippy is endearing and admirable – it’s also – as Simon Price points out (in his excellent Curepedia) it’s a mask, it’s warpaint, it’s what Robert feels comfortable in and it’s also a bit of ‘Theatre’ That’s why we are gathered in this field and boy oh boy that’s what we get.

    The line-up of The Cure is a bit fluid but this is by no means an Echo & The Simple Order situation bordering on ‘triggers broom’ line-up. It isn’t Robert Smith and yer granny on bongos. This is very much yer actual Cure.

    I’m glued to the utter coolness of Simon Gallup – long serving lieutenant who has now reverted to his 1980 era haircut and exudes a fantastic hybrid of Goth and Rockabilly – Gothabilly if you will. Bass slung low, Peter Hook or Paul Simonon style – and pacing the stage like Ronnie Wood in the Stones taking it in turns to interact with everyone on stage (including Gallup jr Eden Gallup who is also on backing guitar duties) – he appears to have the best job and some of the best melody lines in rock to play. There is a moment where he and Robert almost lean on each others backs for a while – rather affecting as they have had their ups and downs but probably need adding to this list.

    The great Roger O’Donnell is on the keys – another Cure veteran of almost 40 years service – looking nowhere near his 70 years and another excellent eyeliner sporter. I don’t know the technical spec but I get the feeling The Cure is very much ‘live’ and nothing much is sequenced so he has his work cut out and delivers every orchestral thunderous drone and the synth pop moments are so key to the Cure sound. Over on lead guitar is Reeves Gabrels who infamously was a key part of Tin Machine and is all over David Bowie’s 90s material. I must confess I wasn’t always a fan of his skronkery but with The Cure he proves he can also fill the role of just serving the song and just playing brilliantly. Every so often The Cure let him out of his box and he is allowed to squall and widdly widdly just a little bit which I think he can be allowed and his solos never outstay their welcome. Holding it down on drums is Jason Cooper – a mere 59 he has been with the band a modest 31 years. He sports a haircut that looks like he’s suspended upside down but is remarkable throughout – nailing the gothic tub thumping and the immense pummelling required of a 27 song Cure set. Cooper junior, Gabriel, also takes an excellent turn on Sax during ‘A Night Like This’.

    The songs? Well unlike many other bands of their vintage ver Cure play a different set each night. On this tour you can expect 25-28 or so songs (they have been known to go on much longer) but they have such a massive catalogue to choose from and while Setlist.fm might give you some idea of what to expect you certainly can’t plan your toilet/bar breaks by it. They get some huge songs away early – ‘Pictures of You’, ‘High’ and ‘Lovesong’ are early doors highlights – songs good enough to build a whole career on. They do an immense twofer of ‘In Between Days’ and ‘Just Like Heaven’ mid set. There are plenty of deep cuts for the diehard fans who jet around and like surprises – the acoustic guitar strumming ‘From the Edge of the Deep Green Sea’ for instance shines like a diamond and is surely a mega Cure hit that never was.

    There is never a sense that I am at a nostalgia event. This is not ‘Goth Rewind’ or ‘Lets Rock Wythenshawe’. The Cure perform and sound like a band very much of our times and for our times – underlined by the epic and thrillingly dark ‘Endsong’ from ‘Songs of a Lost World’ (one of those that builds before several minutes before Robert starts to sing) which ends the main set. They emerge for what is technically an encore but in Cure world, this is a whole 2nd set. It is pretty much back-to-back hits save for ‘Wrong Number’ (a song dropped onto their 1997 hits collection ‘Galore’) a rare misfire in the set with it’s somewhat dated Jesus Jones vibe but you just know someone out there will be overjoyed to hear this oddity. You can forgive that one because we get a joyously stripped back ‘Lovecats’, the inevitable song (it is Friday after all) a glorious ‘Close to Me’ and ending with a hugely uplifting ‘Boys Don’t Cry’. A majestic set overall – it’s Friday and I leave here thoroughly in love with The Cure and all they stand for as the goths and the regulars file out into the night. This is not the end.

  • Deaf School

    Deaf School

    I’ve always been dimly aware of Deaf School. The story goes that between the dissolution of the Beatles and the post-punk scene that sprung up around Eric’s, they (as well as The Real Thing) should have taken the world by storm. Championed by legendary Beatles publicist Derek Taylor, Deaf School were born out of Liverpool Art College and they were not so much Art Rock as Pop Art set to music with brash graphics and a delightfully absurdist line that mixed musical theatre with groovy, sax-driven rock and roll. A Scouse Roxy Music if you will, with a dash of Sensational Alex Harvey and smart songwriting to rival 10CC. A multi-instrumental and visually striking challenge to the scruffy pub-rock and Prog egg n’chippers, shuffling on stage in the same brown-ale stained denim they’d been wearing all week. Deaf School had style by the yard and they wore it well.

    Their debut album came out in 1976 by which time their theatrical swooning seemed a little too 1975 and never quite caught on. Writer Paul Du Noyer said “They don’t sit along any neat continuum. In fact they inhabited a fracture-line between two eras, and they nearly slipped right down it, forever”. They remained, however, the very definition of a cult band. One Kevin Rowland adored them, and their style and swish informs his Dexy’s Midnight Runners to this day. Suggs from Madness liked them so much he married the singer. Liverpool, as Liverpool does, never forget them and has remained fiercely loyal – suffice to say this short tour will end with two big shows at the Philharmonic Hall. They’re here in Hebden Bridge with a smaller but no less enthusiastic crowd to burn them in ready for the weekend.

    For years (in spite of interventions by the aforementioned Mr Du Noyer) I never quite caught on to Deaf School musically – I always liked the idea and the presentation – I couldn’t quite hear it. There is however something increasingly fascinating about the 1970s, as it fades in the rear view mirror and suddenly what may have sounded a bit rinky dink sounds increasingly like something to grasp at and make sense of – what WAS that?. I’m also a great believer in if you really want to understand what a band is all about – go and see them live. It’s about time. I have done my homework and turns out, their debut ‘2nd Honeymoon’ is a remarkable record that rewards a few listens but also the follow-ups ‘English Boys/Working Boys’ and ‘Don’t Stop the World’ (seen as a bit of a mis-step and an attempt to chase the coat tails of The Clash ) are hugely underrated after all.

    As I enter the ever welcoming and brilliant Trades Club I am handed a handkerchief – so already I’m intrigued. More of that later. It is 50 years since their debut LP and wonderfully, six of the original line up are here to play it for us. On comes amazingly youthful Ian Ritchie (who also played the sax on ‘Club Tropicana’ no less and countless others), Steve ‘Average’ holding it down on Bass (and one excellent lead vocal), the amazing Clive Langer (aka Cliff Hanger) on guitar – check out his incredible production credits and over on the keys there is a man in a lime green suit and a vicar’s dog collar – the Reverend Max Ripple is in the house (aka the Emeritus Professor John Wood). They are soon joined with great ovation by the spiv-like wide boy Enrico Cadillac Jnr and the formidable Bette Bright who are about to take us on a very merry dance indeed. Fantastic.

    They glide through most of that debut album, and choice cuts from the others over an hour that flies by. Along the way it’s hard not to be completely charmed by the interaction of Enrico and Bette – singing to each other, slow dancing and seemingly having an ongoing conversation (about lord knows what) whispering sweet nothings between themselves and putting on a proper Pop Art show- but they also interact with the crowd who- in spite of Deaf School being a niche concern, help out on backing vocals singing back every song – they know all the false starts, the cues and the false endings (a Deaf School trademark).

    The band are, as you might expect given the array of talent on the stage, dazzling. Clive Langer in particular is an understated, unflashy, utterly delightful guitarist and the Rev. Ripple – dayglo crucifix around his neck bashes out some piano lines that make it very clear where Mike Barson and Madness got those barrelling music-hall fairground vibes from.

    After a thundering ‘I Wanna Be Your Boy’ (one of those great under-rated tracks of their later record) the sublime title track from ‘2nd Honeymoon’ is the cue for those handkerchiefs we were given to be waved aloft, and another massed singalong followed by the traditional encores of their cover of Flamin’ Groovies ‘Shake Some Action’ and Bette, who has vocally soaring throughout gets to belt out an amazing ‘Final Act’. What a way to end it all. OK I get Deaf School now – maybe they just had to wait for the rest of the world to catch up with them and while it will no doubt be a celebratory shindig this weekend in Liverpool it felt like a real privilege to catch them in a more informal setting in the best venue in the land.

  • Hungry + The Speed of Honey & Her Oscillations + Magnum Opus II

    Hungry + The Speed of Honey & Her Oscillations + Magnum Opus II

    We’ve written before a lot about the excellent Mood Swings nights at Yes Manchester. Hot Take is a variation on that – same deal – 3 bands for less than 1 pint of overpriced lager in The Albert Hall or the arenas – except that Hot Take is all about local Manchester based artists. Same ethos, anything goes and expect the unexpected. Pay yer money and take a chance.

    There’s a really good crowd in from early doors to see the opener – Magnum Opus II. With a name like that I’m expecting something a bit Prog Rock. Not quite but there is a sax player, and some elongated chords guitar being played. It takes me a while to get past the vocalist’s haircut which is an ungainly variation of that sported by Nick Beggs of Kajagoogoo in 1983 (complete with twin pony tail action). However as the music swells and reels us in it’s clear there is more to them than the haircuts. The five piece are firmly in the Art Rock camp – think Eno’s Roxy Music or latter day bands like Black Country New Road. Intense and brooding with some nice noisy bits – but unpretentious – no chin stroking here – indeed the Sax player decides to do a lap of the room while still playing. Rather good – we shall meet again I hope.

    Next up is the brilliantly named The Speed of Honey and Her Oscillations. Formerly a power trio, since forming a mere 12 months ago they have expanded to a six piece although new members seem to keep appearing adding more tambourine and through the haze it’s hard to make out how many are on tiny stage at times. They set their stall out early, shades on, massed guitars and a riff that sounds remarkably like Spacemen 3’s Revolution but isn’t. They wear their influences very clearly (S3, BJM, JAMC, Stooges) but they wear them very well and – when the drummer strikes up a classic Bo Diddley groove they’ve clearly followed some of the rabbit holes those bands set you on to find the source back to the 1960s and 1950s – hopefully they will keep mining. I like the fact that they tap into that slower, dronier, darker side at times and aren’t afraid to lean back into that and stare the audience out. They sound like they’re en-route to somewhere, and maybe need to push it a bit further to get a sound worthy of that excellent band name but yeah – I like their early stuff.

    Last up – Hungry – the singer is already stalking the stage intoning a spoken word part before the band explode. Yes it’s the dreaded Sprechgesang/Post Punk Idles/YardAct/Fontaines/Sleaford talky thing again. I’ve seen a billion bands doing this again and again AND AGAIN AND AGAIN YAAAAH!. Hungry should bore me witless but they don’t – they’re strangely magnetic and they absolutely take the roof off and I enjoy watching them doing it. “If you don’t know what you’re looking at – We ARE HUNGRY!” is a great bit of rhetoric and they immediately get the floor on side and mid way through their singer has the audience sitting down, getting ready to jump up for a mosh and commands the room throughout. It’s full of bluster and energy and movement and while musically they’re not setting my head on fire, Hungry look hungry and they look ready to tear it up around gigs and festivals.

    Quite a night then – and just in case you missed the start- all that for five quid?!

  • Autocamper + Bramwell

    Autocamper + Bramwell

    It’s like Britpop never happened. We are up in the excellent new venue Kamera Ballroom above the Lloyds pub in Chorlton and we appear to have stumbled across an Indie Pop gig to party like it’s 1987. There is a stall selling fanzines, stickers, badges and there are two bands on the bill which have their roots in a particular style and aesthetic that definitely recalls the era before “Indie” became codified as as genre – and at worst middle of the road, meat & potatoes guitar music. Kick In THE SUN….

    This interpretation is summed up by the newly launched streaming service from BBC6Music : “Indie Forever” – where “Indie” means “Nothing but solid gold upbeat indie bangers” – cue Toploader, Razorlight, The Fratellis, Shed Seven and any number of Oasis-adjacent lads and dads purveyors of “anthemic” beery artless slop – Union flag guitars and daft hats. I don’t care how many tracks by the (insert name of ludicrously overhyped viral ‘math rock’ band here) they play – this is a reductive and backwards step.

    Pre 1994 “Indie” meant anything from A.R Kane to PWEI to MBV to The Fall to Scritti Politti to Durutti Column to Cabaret Voltaire to We’ve Got a Fuzzbox and We’re Gonna Use It to The Mighty Lemon Drops to A Guy Called Gerald to KLF to World Domination Enterprises to Loop to Spacemen 3 to Cardiacs to 808 State to Soup Dragons to Mercury Rev to King of the Slums to Microdisney. Even if some of them weren’t on “Indie” labels financially speaking. It wasn’t a genre, it was a catch-all term for a certain way of approaching things. It was what the mid 70s hippy lot tried to call “Rock in Opposition” aka ROI. Imperfect but it certainly wasn’t The Lathams or The Reytons or one of those bands that sounds like a dynasty of local butchers.

    Both turns on the bill tonight, on record at least, remind me of the “indie” music John Peel or Janice Long or in Manchester the ‘Meltdown’ show on BBC Manchester were playing in the late 80s hinterland as Acid House and Hip Hop were taking hold at the same time (and also being played by those DJs). Both bands tonight would quite likely have been snapped up for Creation Records having that mix of smart songwriting, firmly 60s guitar sounds and a certain swagger but also a certain oddness and otherness that they share with all of the above. I get the impression both bands have been absorbing some of that untapped oddness from the era of fanzines, bowlie haircuts and pre-Madchester experimentation before everyone got Loaded.

    First up on what appears to be a double headliner are Bramwell. Formed in Torquay and now Cardiff based. They immediately impress with their way with a tune. Make no mistake – This Is Pop. They’re confident, but this ain’t no Britpop revivalism – they have a quirky feel about them and enough of an oddly psychedelic edge that keeps them on Planet Interesting. Indie Pop is the touchstone – echoes of Felt or Teenage Fanclub but there is a dash of the late 70s about them too – they could be on Stiff Records – I hear a bit of Squeeze, a bit of XTC at their most bouncy. They have 3 singles out all of which should make for a fantastic debut LP if they can only decide on what their sleeve artwork should be. Highlight for me is ‘British Rails (Are Long and Fast)’ and it is long overdue that someone wrote a song about Captain Sensible – Bramwell have..yesss!

    Up next are Autocamper, who I’ve attempted to see more than once and most recently failed as they had an unexpected line-up change as singer and keyboard player Niamh departed for pastures new – cue some regrouping. Their debut ‘What Do You Do All Day‘ is an understated and charming collection of very smart and catchy songs and infectious urgent riffs with a bit of nuance and texture to ’em. Tonight – gone is the swirling organ and vocal interplay between Niamh and other singer/guitarist Jack – instead things take on a more feedback laden raggedy feel- leaning into Velvet Underground or Jesus & MaryChain in their earlier more confrontational era. Mighty fine it is too but I feel like I’ve missed the “Pop” era. It worries me that they may have decided they need to more like the fist-flailing bore-rock of Brian Jonestown Massacre and ditched some of the magic of the debut LP.

    They are leaning into riffing and feedback solos and are in danger of becoming just another ‘Psych’ band (that other heavily codified, and increasingly meaningless title). They do at least not start a fight and exude an energy of looseness and just having fun and there is still something intriguing about the band – a strikingly Jarvis Cocker-alike drummer called Arthur, a bloke on guitar (who annoys me a bit with some over-amplified shrieking – I have to say), a bass player who looks alarmingly like Robert Webb and stage right behind shades is – I presume Jack Harkins who has a bit of the Lawrence from Felt about him (never a bad thing). After 30 mins they decide it’s time for an all-star jam and Bramwell plus a few pals cluster on stage and plug in for a 10 minute freeform take on Them’s garage rock staple ‘Gloria’ – a long time since I’ve seen that happen at a gig and it is rather delightful – reminds of Blue Aeroplanes encores with the massed guitars they used to end each show. I have a nagging feeling this is more to entertain each other and their mates in the crowd rather than the rest of us though – and off they go.

    A very entertaining evening nonetheless. I look forward to Bramwell’s debut LP and, having missed their initial pop phase – with some trepidation -Autocamper’s “difficult 2nd album” and hoping they sharpen their next direction and build on that early promise – (or was this their last show?) Who knows. If You Know – You Know. I don’t.

    Still give me this variant of “Indie” over the fucking Courteeners any day.